Use this to search the site! Just type your request in the blank and click!
Uncle Phaedrus: Consulting Detective and Finder of Lost Recipes

Send Your Requests to:

phaedrus@hungrybrowser.com

Important Pages:

Home
FAQ
Popular Requests
Main Index
Yearly Archives
Links
Puzzlers

Today's Case:

Italian Red Tomato Vinaigrette

Re: Red vinaigrette
From: James
To: Phaedrus 
Date: 4/4/2024, 9:07 AM

On 4/4/2024 2:40 AM, James wrote:

Brother Phaedrus.

RE: "Fillipi's Pizza Grotto" in San Diego, 
website: www.cheesepizza.com 
(which is funny because it's the only place that if you ask for 
extra cheese on a pizza they don't write the extra right away, 
instead just looking at you asking "have you ever eaten here 
before?" (and it's a normal (nice) place, they don't have a 
"Dick's Last Resort" playful vibe.)

So here's the setup:

Fillipi's Restaurants in San Diego County do have a very unusual 
red vinaigrette that they bring out for salad and if you order extra 
for the torpedo sandwich it comes as well. As far as I know it's the 
only vinaigrette that they use.

The recipe you found already is the same one I found online but 
in the restaurant it has chunks of what looks like stewed tomatoes 
in it, it looks like a tomato-based vinaigrette and I've never seen it 
anywhere else.

It's pure sin and unreasonably, UNREASONABLY good. 
The thought of putting tomato in the recipe is off-putting 
(as I lean toward traditional/purist oil & vinegar simplicity) 
but it's the best sub/hoagie/torpedo topping I've ever had. 
They don't put mayo/mustard, just that.

Here's The Proposed Mission Objectives:

Can you find a recipe for Fillipi's Pizza Grotto based in San Diego 
that claims a tomato-based vinaigrette?

If not, I'm still pretty satisfied knowing what you already posted 
for it because you showed that it's red wine vinegar and I hadn't 
thought to use that which reminded me that the other great sub 
vinaigrette I had was also red. That other place with the excellent, 
red, sub vinaigrette is called "Mama's and Papa's Pizza Grotto", 
located in Vista, California (which is North County, San Diego).

The Mamas and Papas Pizza Grotto vinaigrette would also be a 
massive victory in the quest for EXCELLENCE.

Good luck if you choose to go down these paths. 

-Hope to hear back.

-James 

 Hello James,

 Well, I had no success finding any vinaigrette recipes from either "Filippi's Pizza Grotto" or "Mama 'n Papa's Pizza Grotto."

You might be interested in these recipes:

Italian Tomato Vinaigrette

Red Italian House Dressing

Sundried Tomato Vinaigrette

Phaed